Kubotek Forum

KeyCreator CAD & CKD Viewer Technical discussion of CAD/CAM and integrated partner products
Customer Forum > KeyCreator CAD & CKD Viewer > It breaks my heart... View modes: 
User avatar
Valued member
Valued member
Lardo - 11/1/2016 10:13:09 AM
   
It breaks my heart...
AS some of you might know, I'm a pilot and member of the Experimental Aircraft Association. At this years EAA Convention they announced a new member benefit; a free seat of Solidworks. They call it the "EAA Maker Edition". And they're pushing it hard. I just received the follow item, via email, from EAA Hq.

___________________________________________________________________
New EAA Member Benefit; Free SolidWorks
By Cory Puuri, EAA Membership Development Manager, Lifetime 1108982
September 2016 - If you haven’t heard the news, yet, SolidWorks is now available to EAA members as a free member benefit.
Recently announced at EAA AirVenture Oshkosh, the EAA Maker Edition of SolidWorks provides EAAers the ability to create fully detailed parts, assemblies, and drawings; sheet metal patterns; and welded assemblies. It includes wizards to check for interference, you can perform basic stress and flow analysis.
What’s in it for EAA Chapters?
Your chapter can embrace this new benefit and use it to support your member’s design and build projects.
SolidWorks can also be a powerful tool for recruiting new members to your chapter. Online forums around the internet from 3D Printing Central to Maker Spaces have read the news and are posting comments like: “SolidWorks for $40 (the cost of an EAA membership)? Sign me up!!!”
Here are some tactics you can use to recruit such members:
  • Exhibit at a Maker Faire—EAA is working on support tools to help your chapter with this. Please contact the chapters office in the fall to find out more.
  • Conduct SolidWorks Outreach Activities—Visit your local Maker Space, technical college, high school, etc. and post invites to chapter events in which you’ll be conducting building or design activities. Get new people involved with your chapter!
  • Offer SolidWorks Training Seminars—You may not have enough computers to conduct a workshop, but consider hosting a training seminar, and/or invite trainees to bring their laptop computers. You may even want to look up your local SolidWorks Reseller and invite them to participate. If your space is big enough, invite companies that offer related products and services (e.g., hobby stores, service providers from the SolidWorks Manufacturing Network) to exhibit at your event (could be a fundraiser!).
  • Network with SolidWorks User Groups—EAA has included a link on the SolidWorks Resource Center where you can look-up SolidWorks User Groups. Reach out to their contacts and offer to host their events, or invite them to conduct training sessions for your chapter members.
  • Add an Activity Station at Your Young Eagles Rally—You’re probably already using model aircraft flying and building, pedal planes, etc. to entertain the kids while they wait for their flight. Consider adding a display for parents that explains the value of EAA membership and include a SolidWorks demo video or a computer running SolidWorks attached to a 3D printer.
Widespread Popularity
Cirrus, Sonex, and Zenith are among the many aircraft designers using SolidWorks. Zenith has provided a model of its 750 Cruzer for download by EAA members on the EAA Forums. Members can import the sample model into SolidWorks and play “what-if” making modifications to the design.
The EAA Maker Edition license does not include technical support services available with the commercial version; however, EAA members will receive guest membership to MySolidWorks, which includes introductory lessons, access to the SolidWorks Manufacturing Network, SolidWorks Forums and millions of components.
EAA has also recruited nearly two dozen SolidWorks Support Volunteers to answer questions on the EAA Forums.
SolidWorks Student Design Kit—EAA Maker Edition is for personal and educational purposes, but EAA members who desire to commercialize their designs can work with GSC to convert their SolidWorks license.
No matter how you leverage this new member benefit, please let us know how it went by posting a story and pictures in the SolidWorks section on the EAA Forums.
And if you have a particularly cool story to share, please send it to Cory Puuri so he can share it with other members!
For more information, please visit www.EAA.org/SolidWorks.
 
http://www.eaa.org/en/eaa/eaa-chapters/chaptergram-articles/2016-09-new-eaa-member-benefit-free-solidworks

____________________________________________________________________

It breaks my heart to think that many of my aviation brethren are going to be sucked into the "History Vortex". But I guess when you have deep pockets, it's easy give your product away.

I've already heard from a buddy of mine, from Canada, about how exited he is about this perk. I tried to set him straight, but he's already too far gone. Though he did admit that trying to learn Solidwrecks has been confusing and frustrating. So maybe there is hope.

User avatar
Member
Member
jay.d.burkett@gmail.com - 11/1/2016 12:11:23 PM
   
RE:It breaks my heart...
Lardo,

I couldn't agree more.  However, it is a very smart move on the part of Solidworks and the EAA. 

There are still some of us around that remember the dominance that A*cad once held.  This was not because the software was any good, but, rather because of slick marketing and the fact that their software was not copy protected.  The end result was that untold thousands knew a little bit about A*cad.  Even today if you were to ask any mid-level manager to name a CAD software A*cad is usually what they say.

Today, it is Solidworks.  Take a look at the job openings online for CAD drivers --- designers or engineers.  It is either Solidworks or Catia with a smattering of ProE.  Every new grad that we see here has used Solidworks in school.  It has been at least a decade or more since I saw an opening for a Cadkey drafter.  I have never seen any openings that listed KeyCreator experience.

I think that this move by both the EAA and Solidworks is BRILLIANT!  The EAA has undoubtedly increased their membership and will keep doing so as long as Solidworks is a member benefit. 

Getting KeyCreator into the schools would seem to be a logical first step.  Until that is done I doubt we can expect to see any job openings that list KeyCreator experience as a "plus"!


Just my 2¢-worth. 

Jay


 
Jay Burkett
Aerospace Engineer
Fairhope, AL

User avatar
Valued member
Valued member
Lardo - 11/1/2016 1:30:07 PM
   
RE:It breaks my heart...
I couldn't agree with you more, Jay. The advantage SWX (and before it, A-cad) has, is "giving" their product away, for free, to the schools. Get 'em hooked before they know any better. Sad to say, it's more about marketing and less about quality of the product. And know it's gotten to the point where "Solidworks" has become the generic term for CAD. The same way "AutoCAD" was the generic term back in the 80's & 90's.

As for listing for KeyCreator openings is concerned... most non-KC users, who have any knowledge of the old Cadkey, aren't even aware that there has been a name change to the software. Even some of the on-line engineering blogs don't seem to be aware. I go to a few of them, from time to time, and I'll see Cadkey mentioned - but now KeyCreator.

I just get very frustrated with it all. Having years of experience with both KeyCreator & Solidworks, I know that KC is the better program. But Solidworks users won't listen. Because SWX is #1. So it just must be better... right? They certainly don't need to try anything else to know THAT.

Besides... you HAVE to have the history tree. they don't know why, exactly. But you just do. (I've actually had them tell me that.) Then had to them ask me to help them alter an imported body (a.k.a.: dumb solid), that their SWX wouldn't touch. Of course KC does it in it's sleep. Then afterwards still insist you gotta have that history tree.

"????" Ugh!!!

There's only one word to describe that kind of devotion... "indoctrination".

User avatar
Member
Member
George F - 11/3/2016 8:34:22 AM
   
RE:It breaks my heart...
Lardo wrote: ...As for listing for KeyCreator openings is concerned... most non-KC users, who have any knowledge of the old Cadkey, aren't even aware that there has been a name change to the software. Even some of the on-line engineering blogs don't seem to be aware. I go to a few of them, from time to time, and I'll see Cadkey mentioned - but now KeyCreator...


I once received this response when telling a customer what CAD software we use:

"KeyCreator?  Sounds like something for locksmiths to me."

I much preferred the Cadkey name.

User avatar
Valued member
Valued member
Lardo - 11/3/2016 8:54:02 AM
   
RE:It breaks my heart...
Ditto. It even rolls off the tongue easier.

BTW, my earlier post should have read; "...and I'll see Cadkey mention - but not KeyCreator..." (Just call me fumble-fingers.)

User avatar
Valued member
Valued member
Lardo - 11/8/2016 6:09:26 AM
   
RE:It breaks my heart...
Well, according to the SWX thread at the EAA forum, thing aren't going all that smoothly.

______________________________________________________________________

I have been unable to install SolidWorks. Every attempt now provides this sequence:
 
Click the onscreen icon "SOLIDWORKS 2016 x64 Edition Small window opens: "SOLIDWORKS 2016 x64 Edition SP02"
"Please wait while Windows configures SOLIDWORKS 2016 x64 Edition SP02"
 
After the green bar advances to quite near the end of the box, a new small window opens:
"Error 2753. The file 'drawcompare.exe' is not marked for installation"
Click "OK"
 
New small window opens:
"Problem with Shortcut Fatal error during installation.
Click "OK" and the window closes.
 
New small window opens:
"Fatal error during installation."
 
SolidWorks is not installed and this sequence occurs each time I double click the SolidWorks icon. SolidWorks promises no technical support for the EAA student version. So far, SolidWorks has kept its promise.

____________________________________________________________________

1
Login